- Sinners has the shortest odds to win best horror film at the 2025 Critics Choice Super Awards at -370.
- The Substance, Nosferatu, and Heretic all have under +1000 odds to win the award.
NEW YORK – The Critics Choice Super Awards return Thursday, August 7th at 9 PM PT for the fifth edition of the annual event. Amongst the most anticipated categories is Best Horror Movie
Best Horror Movie Winner Odds
- Sinners -370
- The Substance +750
- Nosferatu +850
- Heretic +850
- Longlegs +1000
- Bring Her Back +1600
Sinners comes in as a heavy favorite at online sportsbooks with -370 odds to win best horror film, followed by The Substance at +750.
The film, starring Michael B. Jordan and directed by Ryan Coogler, earned the ninth best opening weekend of all-time for an R-rated movie, according to ScreenRant. It is no surprise to see Sinners atop the odds to win yet another honor.
The Substance features Demi Moore in the lead role, which she earned numerous awards for. The film grossed $77-82 million on an $18 budget, so it is safe to say that it was a hit at the box office.
Nosferatu is an older story which was reproduced in 2024, grossing over $180 million worldwide. It has earned multiple nominations for cinematography and costume design, as well as earning one of the final spots for horror movie of the year.
Advertising Disclosure
USAOnlineSportsbooks.com provides you with the most current information regarding sports betting and fantasy with the help of commissions we receive from links you may click on our site.
Heretic incorporates psychological horror as well as religion to create one of the most interesting movies of the year, earning Hugh Grant a Golden Globe nomination for best actor.
Longlegs features Nicolas Cage in a story following a serial killer, which would end up grossing over $100 million worldwide. Despite this, the film has just +1000 odds to win the award.
Lastly, Bring Her Back sits at +1600 odds to win the award. The Australian film is described as a supernatural psychological horror and grossed just over $20 million worldwide. It received overwhelmingly positive reviews, but did not quite achieve the reach it hoped for.
The final verdict ultimately comes down to whether or not Sinners could possibly lose this award, which seems quite unlikely considering its historic box office performance. At -370 odds on entertainment sportsbooks, it seems that the outcome has already been decided.
Drew is currently a student at Florida State University majoring in Communication / Media Studies. He enjoys playing, watching, reading, and writing about sports. If you need to know anything about football or basketball, Drew’s your guy.
